Read

Join Us!
Read
Fuckup Stories

The system has (we have) failed the environment

Before falling into despair, let us stop for a moment and take a closer look at climate catastrophism.

By:
Shanti Banus
The system has (we have) failed the environment

So here we are, contemplating the fragile state of our environment with feelings of anxiety and distress. This is what embodies climate catastrophism: a shared apprehension that convinces us that Mother Earth has suffered irreversible damage that leaves us helpless. 

However, narratives focused on catastrophism may not be the most effective means of inspiring action, and there is much more to this issue than meets the eye. And while we are on the subject of environmental catastrophism, it is crucial to introduce us to the concept of environmental racism, as they go hand in hand. Before we succumb to a sense of despair, let's pause for a moment and examine these issues more closely.

Environmental racism and the development of the environmental justice movement

In the 1960s and 1970s, when bell-bottoms were all the rage and disco music reigned in nightclubs, low-income communities were conveniently ignored in environmental decision-making processes. Surprise, surprise! These populations, made up mostly of racialized people (indigenous, Afro-descendants, Asians), suffered first-hand from industrial pollution, toxic waste dumps and many other environmental hazards.

In the 1980s and 1990s, the environmental justice movement emerged in response to these injustices, advocating for fair treatment and meaningful participation of all people in environmental policy. A notable figure in the environmental justice movement is Hazel M. Johnson, also known as the "Mother of Environmental Justice." Johnson documented the ecological health issues facing her community in Chicago, shedding light on the unequal distribution of environmental burdens. Her work helped catalyze the movement and raise awareness of the repercussions of environmental racism.

Persistence of environmental racism

Despite the efforts of the environmental justice movement, environmental racism continues. Communities of racialized people, especially indigenous people, continue to bear the brunt of environmental hazards, resulting in severe health consequences and significantly reduced quality of life. The complex relationships between race, ethnicity, class, segregation, discrimination and disease contribute to these disparities.

To effectively combat environmental racism, it is crucial to address the systemic factors that perpetuate these inequalities. This requires recognizing the need for intersectional approaches that take into account the unique experiences and challenges faced by different populations.

The impact of climate catastrophism on our mental health and environment

Climate catastrophism is not just about having a negative mindset about the current state of the environment. It can seriously affect us. It has profound psychological repercussions, such as feelings of hopelessness, anxiety and despair. This leads to inaction and lack of commitment to addressing climate change. Furthermore, climate catastrophism undermines all the environmental efforts that have been made and disempowers communities that are defending the Earth on the front lines.

The pessimistic view of the direction of the environment is wreaking disproportionate havoc on historically marginalized populations. It is like a scare tactic in full force, hitting these populations the hardest and exacerbating existing inequalities. And let's not forget the lack of diversity in the scientific arena: when only a limited group of people are listened to, we miss out on diverse perspectives that could shed light on pressing issues such as climate change.

Communities of color are already facing the harsh reality of the climate crisis, but their voices and experiences are often drowned out in the sea of pessimism. And guess what? Climate catastrophism conveniently deflects blame away from corporate and institutional responsibility, leaving the white supremacy of the system intact. You know we like to call a spade a spade ;)

The intersection between environmental catastrophism and environmental racism

The intersection between environmental catastrophism and environmental racism further exacerbates existing inequalities and disempowers communities of racialized people. Environmental racism disproportionately affects these populations, making them more vulnerable to the effects of climate change. In turn, climate catastrophism perpetuates environmental injustices by diverting attention from systemic oppression and neglecting the voices and experiences of struggling indigenous populations.

So, the next time you argue with someone because they are not vegan or because they brush their teeth with a bamboo toothbrush, think twice. Many times these choices and feelings of superiority stem from privilege. By recognizing the intersectionality of these issues, we can work towards collective action and address systemic inequalities from a holistic point of view.

Coping with climate catastrophism

Addressing climate catastrophism requires acknowledging collective vulnerability and giving space to others. By validating complex emotions and engaging in meaningful conversations, we can build resilience and empower the broader population to take action. The historical resilience of movements like the environmental justice movement demonstrates the power of indigenous communities to create sustainable change.

Education and engagement of all people play a critical role in the fight against climate catastrophism. By raising awareness and sharing knowledge, we can invite people to challenge dominant narratives and amplify the voices of historically oppressed populations. In addition, validating the emotions and experiences of those affected by climate catastrophism is crucial to building trust and fostering collective action.

In short, as expected, the system has failed us when it comes to protecting the environment and historically violated communities. But we are not going to sit back and accept it. It is time to question the status quo, analyze the failures of our system and discuss strategies for change. If we tackle climate catastrophism and environmental racism head-on, take collective action and cede our power to the indigenous communities who are defending the planet. Then we can create a world that is not only environmentally sustainable, but also equitable for all.

---

Create safe spaces in your company so that people can have these difficult conversations out of vulnerability. Our online course on difficult conversations will give your team the tools to explore solutions out of curiosity and not fear. Fill out this form and you will receive the information you need to decide to transform your organizational culture.

Edited by

Raquel Rojas

The system has (we have) failed the environment
Shanti Banus
Community Manager & Writer
funfunfunfun

Comments

Related COntent
Bring Fuckup Nights to your organization!
Bring Fuckup Nights to your organization!

Let's transform our perception of failure and use it as a catalyst for growth.